Joseph Butters


When four year old Joseph Butters left for preschool one morning in 2003, his family couldn’t possibly have known the traumatic event that was about to occur.

The Kohanga Reo van that he was travelling in, with nine other children, collided with a freight train in Wanganui.  Flashing lights and bells were working at the crossing at the time.

“We are so lucky we still have him,” his mother Suzanne Butters says.  “The doctors initially only gave him a five percent chance of surviving. 

He spent two weeks in a coma on life support, and after that we spent over three months in the Wilson Rehabilitation Centre in Auckland, where Joe had to learn to eat, walk and talk all over again. “

Apart from a few “beauty” scars on his forehead, Joe’s injuries are not immediately obvious, but he now struggles with a lifelong brain injury.

“The events of that morning are affecting him now and will affect him for the rest of his life,” says Suzanne.  “Joseph will never be the child he was going to be and we are still very much in un-chartered waters.

“He is doing really well and making progress, but he is behind his peers cognitively, and we just don’t know what lies ahead for him.  Fatigue is also a huge issue.”

The past eight years have been a challenge for the whole Butters family.  At times Suzanne has found day to day life difficult to cope with, and she had to give up her job to care for Joseph following the collision.

However Suzanne says there is one saving grace which is that Joseph has no memory of the collision.  “I’m not sure about the other children who were in the van that day – they could very well still have nightmares,” she says. 

Sue now works as a diversional therapist for a brain rehabilitation centre in Wanganui, and drives over the same crossing every day.

“I see cars that don’t slow down and don’t even look for trains, and I think to myself, if only they knew.

“People just need to take time and pay attention, because the consequences are just not worth it.”

Share this story with others

[image] Facbook icon - Join us on facebookFacebook [image] Twitter icon - Join us on twitterTwitter

More of your stories

  • Nicole Vreugdenhil “It's amazing I survived at all”
  • Roni Jacobs “We now always stop at a Stop sign”
  • Ian Thornton “I've lost count of how many near misses I've had”
  • Cathy Turner “I miss my son Michael every day”
  • Joseph Butters “He will never be the boy he was going to be”
  • Mike Kilsby “It impacts on all your family and friends”
  • Paul Johansen “I wouldn't wish it on anyone, and I wish I hadn't been there”
  • Ray Burgess “They thought I would die so I know I'm one of the lucky ones”
  • Willy Palmer “We never want to see the horrific things we do”

Keeping safe

Your stories
Latest news

Safety Leadership Award Announced

Friday, February 17, 2017

Rail industry safety expert Robert (Bob) Lupton was today announced as the inaugural winner of the TrackSAFE NZ Safety Leadership Award. 

The award was established late last year to recognise significant leadership in railway safety in New Zealand.

Chairman of TrackSAFE NZ Peter Reidy says Mr Lupton received the award for his outstanding contribution to safety over his 32 year career in New Zealand and overseas.

“Mr Lupton’s continued contribution has appreciably influenced rail safety in New Zealand across a number of organisations,” Mr Reidy says.  “He has an outstanding reputation for providing sound advice and growing and supporting those around him and is fully deserving of this special award.”

Mr Lupton has worked in a number of roles in the rail industry throughout his career, most recently as the Rail Systems Safety and Assurance Manager for the City Rail Link project.   

In that role he provided leadership, mentoring and guidance to the City Rail Link safety assurance and construction safety teams.

Among Mr Lupton’s many achievements are leading the development of the Britomart Safety Management System and responsibility for safety management during the transition to Auckland’s electrified network.  This included crashworthiness risk assessments for the new Auckland electric rolling stock.

Mr Lupton is an executive member of the New Zealand National Rail System Standards Executive committee, and continues to provide expert rail safety advice to the City Rail Link one of New Zealand's largest transport projects.

The award was presented today to Mr Lupton at Auckland Transport offices, in front of industry representatives.  Read more

Privacy policy © Copyright 2014 trackSAFE